Essix or Hawley retainer, which one actually fits you
Share
An Essix retainer is a clear plastic tray you order online for $139 an arch. A Hawley retainer is an acrylic plate with a visible wire, built chairside by an orthodontist.
Both hold your teeth where braces or aligners left them. The difference is how they look, how long they last, and how you get one.
What each one is built from
Essix retainers are vacuum-formed clear plastic, molded straight over your teeth. There is no metal anywhere, which is why they disappear when you talk.
A Hawley retainer is older technology, a pink acrylic plate that sits against the roof or floor of your mouth, held by a thin metal wire across the front of your teeth.
The comparison people are actually running
Essix against Hawley, side by side
| Question | Essix retainer | Hawley retainer |
|---|---|---|
| What it is made of | Clear thermoplastic tray | Acrylic plate with a metal wire |
| How visible it is | Nearly invisible | The wire shows across your teeth |
| Can it be adjusted later | No, a new tray is made instead | Yes, a dentist can bend the wire |
| Where you get one | $139 online, no office visit | In an orthodontist's office |
| Typical lifespan | 1 to 2 years | Longer, often 5 or more years |
We build Essix retainers only. Hawley retainers are made chairside by an orthodontist, listed here for comparison.
Where each one wins
Essix wins on looks and on getting started. Nothing shows, and there is no appointment between you and a finished retainer, just an at home impression kit and a wait of a few weeks.
Hawley wins on lifespan and on fine tuning. A dentist can bend the wire years into ownership if a tooth drifts slightly, something a clear tray cannot do.
Ordering an Essix retainer
- The impression kit reaches you by USPS in 3 days or FedEx overnight.
- You take the impressions at home and mail them back with the prepaid label.
- We check your photos before anything is built.
- The retainer arrives 14 to 28 days later, made in the USA.
Health account cards work at checkout, and how HSA and FSA payment works covers the receipt you may need.
Questions people actually ask
Which retainer is cheaper, Essix or Hawley
An Essix retainer from Smile Lab USA is 149 dollars for one arch with no office visit. A Hawley retainer is made chairside by an orthodontist, and its price sits with that office.
Which retainer lasts longer
Hawley, generally. The acrylic plate and wire hold up for years and the wire can be adjusted, while a thin Essix tray is usually replaced after a year or two.
Why do most people pick Essix anyway
It is clear, so nobody sees it, and it ships from an at home impression kit instead of an office appointment. For most people that trade beats a longer lasting wire they can see.
Can an Essix retainer be adjusted like a Hawley
No. A Hawley wire can be bent by a dentist to fine tune the fit. An Essix tray cannot be adjusted, so a new impression and a new tray is the fix if teeth shift.
Is an Essix retainer HSA and FSA eligible
Orthodontic retainers are listed as medical expenses in IRS Publication 502, so it is normally eligible. Your plan administrator makes the final determination.
Filling a missing tooth with the same clear tray, read the Essix retainer with a fake tooth guide. Full pricing is on the Essix Pontic Retainer page.
Smile Lab USA builds every retainer in Hollywood, Florida, backed by a 60 day manufacturer warranty.